IKEA TROFAST vs a plastic-bin toy organiser
IKEA’s TROFAST and a ready-made plastic-bin toy organiser are trying to do the same job: give children’s toys a visible, child-height home in separate tubs, rather than one toy chest. The difference is in the shape, how you buy it, and how it will sit in a small UK room. One is a slim, modular frame you build and add to; the other is a wider, complete unit that arrives as a set of bins on a stand.
This is desk research, not a hands-on test, and it is not a “winner takes all” review. We compared published dimensions and features from retailer listings, and we point you to our ranked toy storage list for the wider shortlist. Prices change, so use the product links to check the current price. IKEA links are editorial only; they are not affiliate links.
Affiliate disclosure: We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. IKEA links are not affiliate links. Read our full disclosure.
The two options, side by side
On our toy-storage shortlist, the IKEA example is the TROFAST storage combination with boxes, white/white, listed at 46 x 30 x 94 cm. It is a narrow, tall-ish frame with pull-out boxes, and the TROFAST range is modular: different frame sizes, open shelves and box colours are sold separately, so many UK families grow the system over time.
The ready-made comparison is the Amazon Basics kids toy storage organiser with 12 plastic bins, our number one toy-storage pick, listed at 85.3 x 27.7 x 79 cm. Twelve bins sit on a low, open frame. The listing says the frame is reinforced with metal dowels and anchors to the wall.
A close high-street cousin is the Argos Home kids 4-tier basket unit, listed at 86 x 30 x 80.5 cm, with twelve removable baskets. Argos says it is stackable and folds flat if you move house.
So in broad terms: TROFAST as listed here is about 46 cm wide and 94 cm tall; the Amazon Basics and Argos organisers are about 85–86 cm wide and around 80 cm tall. Depths are similar, in the 28–30 cm range. Those numbers, not the brand names, should drive the first decision.
Room fit: slim alcove or a wider wall
If you have a narrow gap — beside a wardrobe, in a chimney-breast alcove, at the end of a bed — TROFAST’s 46 cm width is the stronger starting point. A unit that is nearly 86 cm wide will not go there, no matter how good the bins are.
If you have a clear stretch of wall in a living room or play area, the wider organiser can be more useful. Twelve shallow bins in a lower, longer run give more categories at a height a toddler can see, without going as tall as 94 cm. In a room where you also want the piece to sit under a window or beside a sofa, check the window ledge and radiator: 79–80 cm is a typical low-furniture height, but you must measure your own sill.
Depth is tight on all three: roughly 28–30 cm. That is shallow enough for many small rooms, but still worth subtracting from a narrow walkway. Our small living room toy storage guide looks at placing units on the edges of the room rather than in the middle.
How children actually use the bins
Both styles work when each bin has one job: cars, bricks, play food, crayons. Labels or a picture on the front help pre-readers.
TROFAST boxes slide like shallow drawers. They can be pulled out and, depending on the box, carried to the rug. The slimmer frame means fewer boxes in one footprint, so you may need a second frame or extra storage for a large collection. That is also the appeal: you add a frame later instead of buying a wide unit now.
The Amazon Basics style is a grid of lift-out plastic bins. A child can take one bin away and, in theory, bring it back. Twelve bins sound a lot; you do not have to fill them. Empty bins are better than a unit stuffed with mixed oddments. The Argos baskets do a similar job in fabric rather than hard plastic — quieter on a living-room floor, and a little less “visible” if you like to hide visual noise.
Neither system is good as a dump for Lego in one giant tub. Many-pieced sets need their own sorted containers. See Lego storage ideas.
Buying, adding and moving house
TROFAST is a system. The combination on our list is a useful starter, but the reason families like it is the ability to add boxes, change layouts and match other TROFAST frames around the house. You should check current IKEA stock for the exact boxes included in any combination, because bundles change. The extra trips and the build time are the cost of that flexibility.
A 12-bin organiser is a complete product. You know how many bins you are getting, and it has a single footprint. Adding more later usually means buying a second unit, not a couple of extra official boxes (unless you find bins that happen to fit — measure before you assume).
If you move often or you are in rented rooms, the Argos unit’s fold-flat claim is worth a look, according to the listing. A wooden IKEA frame is more of a proper piece of furniture; it will need to be dismantled and rebuilt. Neither is “better”; it depends how settled you are.
We are not quoting prices here. TROFAST can look cheaper as a small starter frame and more expensive once you have several boxes and a second unit. A 12-bin organiser can look better value as a single purchase. Check both listings on the day you buy, including delivery.
Safety and look
Fix either type to the wall if the listing includes an anchor. Children climb storage. The Amazon Basics listing specifically mentions wall anchoring; IKEA frames should be fixed as the instructions require. Do not skip this because the unit looks low.
On looks: TROFAST is a familiar, slightly “playroom” aesthetic that many UK homes already have. A white 12-bin organiser is also clearly for toys; it will not disguise itself as adult furniture. If you need the living room to look calmer in the evening, a low cube unit with fabric boxes — such as the Vida Designs Durham on our cube storage list — may sit better, with the bins kept in a bedroom.
Which should you choose?
Choose TROFAST if the gap you have is narrow, you like the idea of adding frames later, or you already own TROFAST boxes that you want to keep using. Treat it as a modular system, not a one-off box.
Choose a 12-bin organiser if you have a wider wall, you want many categories in one low unit on day one, and you would rather buy a complete product. The Amazon Basics unit is our top-scored option of this type; the Argos unit is the high-street alternative with folding in its favour, according to the listing.
Choose neither as your only storage if most of the problem is bulky toys and dressing-up. Add a lidded box, such as a Wham 25 L or a Really Useful 64 L, for the things that will not go in a shallow bin.
A rotation system is often what makes either option work day to day; see our toy rotation storage ideas. If you only need one or two boxes rather than a full unit, start with the best toy boxes for toddlers.
FAQs
Is IKEA TROFAST better than a plastic-bin toy organiser?
It is better when you need a slim, modular frame. A 12-bin organiser is better when you want more categories in a wider, slightly lower unit. Fit comes first.
How wide is TROFAST compared with a 12-bin unit?
The TROFAST combination on our list is 46 cm wide. The Amazon Basics and Argos organisers we compared are about 85–86 cm wide. Depths are similar, at around 28–30 cm.
Can I mix TROFAST boxes with another brand of frame?
Only if you have measured both. Official TROFAST boxes are made for TROFAST frames. Do not assume a plastic bin will slide, or that a TROFAST box will sit safely on another stand.
Which is better for a small living room?
The one that fits the wall you will actually use. In a narrow alcove, TROFAST. Along a longer sofa wall, a low 12-bin unit, or cubes with fabric boxes if you want it to look less like a playroom.
Do I need to fix them to the wall?
Yes, if children can climb them and the instructions include a wall anchor. Treat this as part of the purchase, not an optional extra.
